Should you pay your child for chores? What the research says

Sooner or later, a child asks how much they will get for taking the bin out. Some parents happily pay, because it shows that money is earned. Others feel that you help at home simply because it is your home. Researchers have studied this question for more than half a century, and what they found points to a middle way.
The answer in one sentence
What happens when helping is paid
In 2008, Felix Warneken and Michael Tomasello at the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig tested this with 20-month-olds. The toddlers were keen to help an adult, for example by handing back something the adult had dropped. One group got a material reward for helping, another got only praise, and a third got nothing. Then the children were given more chances to help. Those who had been rewarded before helped less often than the others.
The authors explain it like this. A young child's wish to help comes on its own, and a material reward can weaken it.

Psychologists had seen something similar back in 1973. Mark Lepper, David Greene, and Richard Nisbett worked with preschoolers. They picked children who already liked drawing with felt tips. Some were promised a "Good Player" certificate for their drawings, some were given the same certificate as a surprise, and some got nothing. Later, in free play, the children who had drawn for the promised certificate picked up the felt tips less often than the rest. The surprise reward made little difference.
In 1999, Edward Deci, Richard Koestner, and Richard Ryan brought together 128 experiments on rewards. They reached a similar conclusion. Tangible rewards, money included, can reduce interest in something a person already enjoyed.
So is money harmful?
Rewards are neither good nor bad in themselves. In his lecture at Stanford, Mark Lepper stresses that it all depends on how they are used.
The Harvard economist Roland Fryer paid school pupils for different things in several American cities. Paying for grades and test scores did not improve anything. In Dallas, though, second graders were paid 2 dollars for every book they read, as long as they passed a short quiz on it. These children read more. Fryer concluded that paying for a concrete action a child can take works better than paying for a result the child does not know how to reach.
How to combine pocket money and chores
The Australian parenting site Raising Children Network describes several approaches. Some families believe everyone should help at home, so they do not pay for chores. The site warns that when money is tied to every job, a child may start bargaining over what taking the bin out is worth. Other families give pocket money separately from chores and pay extra for extra work.
A parent guide from the Government of South Australia says the same. Many parents give pocket money simply because the child is part of the family, and more can be earned through extra jobs, such as washing the car.
Here is one way to set it up at home.
- Make a list with your child of the daily jobs everyone in the family does (make the bed, clear your own plate, feed the cat). These are not paid.
- Give pocket money on the same day each week, whatever happens with the list.
- Write a separate list of extra jobs that can earn money (wash the car, rake the leaves, sort out the toy cupboard). Let your child decide whether to take them on.
- Pay for the work itself once it is finished, the way Fryer paid for a book that had been read.
- Agree on the price in advance and keep it the same from week to week.
- Talk about what your child will spend the money on. The US Consumer Financial Protection Bureau suggests guiding children in managing the money they earn and talking about their plans for it.
Praise works differently
The Warneken and Tomasello study had one more group that people often forget. Toddlers who were only praised for helping went on to help more often than those who got a reward. A kind word did not crowd out the wish to help.
So when your child lays the table, the best pay is simple. Notice it and say exactly what went well. And if your family keeps a list of jobs and of goals your child is saving for, let it show both columns, what we do together and what your child earned on their own.